Warsh sets out three AI scenarios for the US economy, one with falling stock valuations
Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh said Board staff are modeling illustrative paths for growth and jobs, and stressed they are not forecasts.
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh said on Monday that the Board's staff has begun testing three illustrative scenarios for how "super intelligence" could change US growth and jobs, one of them ending in lower stock valuations and a slowdown. He spoke in opening remarks at a Fed conference in San Francisco.
Three paths, none of them a forecast
The remarks opened the Productivity and Jobs Task Force Conference, hosted by the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. Warsh said the task force is one of five he has convened as chairman, and that it was his first visit to a Reserve Bank in that role.
Warsh said the Board's staff "has begun to evaluate various contingencies, applying stylized, model-based frameworks to generate scenarios." He called them "illustrative scenarios, not forecasts" and said that "many other outcomes ... could be drawn."
- Broad gains. Technology raises productivity and the gains are "shared broadly across labor and the owners of capital." Real GDP growth rises persistently above its long-run average and the US stays close to full employment.
- Disruption. Some jobs are "displaced, rather than complemented, by technology." Growth would still exceed its long-term average, but automation combined with labor market frictions "could push the jobless rate above levels consistent with full employment."
- Disappointment. After "significant capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns could turn down and equity valuations could fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment." In time, Warsh said, "the economy would recover, but without the productivity gains."
Why Warsh says this technology may differ from earlier ones
Warsh described "super intelligence" as "an entirely new force in economic life and society." He argued that earlier general-purpose technologies, such as the internal combustion engine and electricity, "did not themselves automate the creation of ideas," while this one "could supercharge idea generation."
He also noted the starting point. Productivity growth "has fluctuated, and in recent quarters, it's been reasonably strong," he said, but "it hasn't yet broken out definitively and structurally to the upside."
What the Fed says it does not know
Warsh framed the Fed's role as neutral. "At the Fed, our role in all this is neither advocacy nor opposition," he said. He said the widespread adoption of the technology "will have significant impact on the economy, with important implications for monetary policy down the road."
He listed the open questions as "magnitude, scope, and timing": whether total factor productivity rises, when a surge would start and taper, and whether it would come sooner in the US than elsewhere. "I expect much more clarity with the passing of time," he said.
He also pointed to security risks. The technology "empowers all, including bad actors," he said, so the Fed is "thinking especially of critical infrastructures and their potential vulnerabilities."
We would read the third scenario as a question about prices, not about technology
We think the most useful part of the remarks is the scenario the Fed chose to name last. Warsh described it as the one in which expected returns and equity valuations fall after heavy investment, and he attached an unemployment cost to it. That ties the technology question to the financial conditions the Fed already watches, and it is a sign that staff are modeling asset prices as well as productivity.
The opportunity is the first scenario, where growth runs above its long-run average without a rise in unemployment. The threat is that the three paths can look the same for a long time: Warsh himself said the timing is unknown. Our reading is that no single quarter of productivity data will settle which path the US is on, and that the Fed's stated neutrality means policy would follow measured outcomes rather than expectations.
We would weigh several quarters of productivity and unemployment figures together, and we would change this view if staff publish scenario results with numbers attached. If productivity growth fades back toward its past pace while valuations stay high, we would expect the third scenario to get more attention in Fed communications. That is a forecast, not a certainty.
The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.
Sources
- Opening Remarks, Chairman Kevin Warsh, Productivity and Jobs Task Force Conference — Federal Reserve BoardPrimary source
More in Economy
View All Economy


