Binance wins a $6.5 billion Abu Dhabi freezing order that can be served on blockchain

The order targets the unknown perpetrators of the October 29 theft; the US Justice Department said on November 12 that more than $2.7 billion has been frozen.

Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
Illustration of a wall of safe-deposit boxes with most doors padlocked and one left open and empty in a dim vault
Illustration. Not a photo of any exchange, court or vault.Illustration: FinanceInTime

Binance has obtained a worldwide freezing order of $6.5 billion from the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Courts against the unknown perpetrators of its October 29 theft, the exchange said in a post dated November 18. The US Justice Department attributes the theft to North Korea's TraderTraitor group.

The order follows the theft that FinanceInTime reported on November 2, when the FBI named TraderTraitor.

An order aimed at unknown hackers and 26,000 wallets

Binance's post says the exchange "has been granted a court order in the Abu Dhabi Global Markets (ADGM) Courts" to support the recovery of assets connected to the incident.

Decrypt reported that the $6.5 billion order is against unknown perpetrators and can be served via the blockchain. Market participants are notified of a "living list" of 26,000 wallet addresses identified as holding stolen assets, according to Kendall Day, a partner at Gibson Dunn, Binance's law firm. Day said that list will enable "those assets to be frozen rapidly even as they are laundered at pace".

CoinDesk reported that the order bars companies including the stablecoin issuer Circle and the custodian BitGo from moving the stolen assets. CoinDesk wrote that court documents do not accuse those firms of wrongdoing.

Why issuers want a court order before they release anything

Binance said that "in some cases, issuers, exchanges or other partners request a formal court order before frozen assets will be released, transferred or returned." The order, in Binance's description, supports that step of the recovery.

A separate part of the case concerns assets that are already frozen. CoinDesk reported, citing Reuters, that the court is set to consider on December 1 whether 18 firms must hand over assets they have already frozen.

Binance said that "users are protected" and that "this process will take time". According to CoinDesk, Binance has said it already replaced the assets stolen from its wallets after committing more than $6.34 billion.

Five figures that measure different things

The amounts in circulation differ by source and by date, and they measure different things.

Figure Source What it covers
$6.5 billion Decrypt, CoinDesk Size of the ADGM freezing order
More than $6 billion US Justice Department, November 12 Virtual assets stolen on or about October 29
More than $2.7 billion US Justice Department, November 12 Frozen by US government and private-sector efforts
More than $1.2 billion US Justice Department, November 12 Court-authorized seizure or restraint within that amount
About $2.85 billion CoinDesk Frozen or intercepted by third parties

The Justice Department said its Criminal Division helped "immediately halt about half of this historic breach." The department's figures are from November 12; the CoinDesk figure is from the report of November 19. The sources do not say whether the $2.85 billion and the $2.7 billion describe the same assets.

A freeze keeps the money in place but does not say whose it is

We think the order is better read as a legal tool than as a recovery. Max Atallah, managing partner at Nordic Law, is quoted by CoinDesk as saying: "A freeze does not in itself determine who is entitled to the assets." The December 1 hearing, and the issuers' wish for a court order before releasing anything, show where the work now sits: with courts and custodians, not with the chain.

The opportunity is speed. A blockchain-served order and a shared address list can reach funds while they are still moving, while the Justice Department said its Criminal Division and partners halted about half of the breach. The threat is that ether and bitcoin cannot be frozen by an issuer, and neither source says how much of the stolen amount sits in them now.

We expect more exchanges to seek orders of this kind if they prove enforceable against issuers and custodians, and we do not forecast price levels. We would change our view if the December 1 hearing leaves the frozen assets with the firms that hold them, or if Binance reports how much has actually been returned.

The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.

Sources

  1. Binance Has Been Granted a Court Order in the ADGM Courts to Support Asset Recovery — BinancePrimary source
  2. Justice Department Announces Actions to Disrupt North Korea's Massive Theft of Cryptocurrency — US Department of JusticePrimary source
  3. Binance wins $6.5 billion freezing order against hackers behind crypto's largest theft — CoinDeskSecondary source
  4. Binance Wins $6.5B Freezing Order Over Hack That Can Be Served via the Blockchain — DecryptSecondary source
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google

More in Crypto

View All Crypto

Get Finance News in Your Inbox

Daily headlines, market insights and analysis from our editors.