New homes need 33% of median income for the payment, existing homes 36%, NAHB index shows
The NAHB/Wells Fargo index puts the median new house $39,600 below the median existing home in the third quarter; San Jose needs 79% of income, Decatur 17%.
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
A median-income US family needed 33% of its income for the mortgage payment on a median-priced new home in the third quarter of 2026, against 36% for a median-priced existing home, according to the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Cost of Housing Index, published on Thursday.
A $39,600 price gap behind a three-point difference
The index uses a national median new-home price of $393,300 for the third quarter, down 4.2% from $410,700 in the second quarter. The existing-home median was $432,900, down 0.5% from $434,900. The gap between the two is $39,600, and the new-home price is 9.1% below the existing-home price (both computed). NAHB's analysis calls the nearly $40,000 gap the reason new construction stayed more affordable relative to existing homes. The release does not say why the new-home median fell faster than the existing-home median.
For a family earning the national median income of $106,800, the share of income needed for a new home slipped to 33% from 34% in the second quarter. For a low-income family, defined as one earning 50% of the median, the share was 66% for a new home, down from 67%, and 73% for an existing home.
The same payment takes 79% of income in San Jose and 17% in Decatur
The index also covers 175 metropolitan areas, using local median prices and incomes for existing homes. In eight of them the typical family is severely cost-burdened, meaning a payment of more than 50% of income. Another 87 markets are cost-burdened, at 31% to 50%, and 80 markets are at 30% or lower (the three groups add up to 175, computed).
San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, California, was the most severely cost-burdened at 79%, followed by Urban Honolulu at 73%, San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad at 70%, San Francisco-Oakland-Fremont at 66% and Barnstable Town, Massachusetts, at 61%. Decatur, Illinois, was the least burdened at 17%, ahead of Elmira, New York, at 18% and Peoria, Illinois, at 19%. In the five most burdened markets, low-income families would need between 122% and 157% of their income for the payment.
Third-quarter figures that predate October's rate climb
The index covers July through September and is a quarterly series, so it does not capture what has happened since. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) reported on November 12 that existing-home sales fell 5.5% in October to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.75 million, and that the median existing-home price rose 0.4% to $416,700. That is a monthly NAR figure from a different series, not comparable with the index's third-quarter median of $432,900. FinanceInTime covered the sales report and the mortgage rates that accompanied it.
Affordability that depends on the builders' price, not on rates
Our reading is that the index shows where housing is cheapest to enter, not that it is cheap. A 33% payment share is above the 30% line the index uses for burdened households, and it sits on a new-home median that fell 4.2% in one quarter, a move we would not assume repeats. The threat is that a new-home advantage built on lower prices narrows if builders stop cutting; the opportunity is that more new supply, where buyers can afford it, restores choice that high mortgage rates removed from the resale market. We expect the payment share to follow mortgage rates more than prices over the next six to twelve months, if rates stay near current levels the 33% would not fall much. Regional gaps will stay wide: a 62-percentage-point spread between San Jose and Decatur is not a rate story. We would be wrong if the fourth-quarter index shows existing-home prices falling faster than new-home prices.
The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.
Sources
- Large Median Price Gap Keeps New Homes More Affordable Than Existing Homes — National Association of Home Builders (Eye on Housing)Primary source
- Existing-Home Sales Decreased 5.5% in October — National Association of RealtorsPrimary source
More in Real Estate
View All Real Estate


