A New York judge hears a bid to restrain Kalshi on Monday after the CFTC lost its request

The state asks Justice Melissa Crane for an order barring Kalshi from running what it calls an unlicensed gambling business; Kalshi says it would shut the exchange for every customer.

Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
Illustration of a marble courthouse corridor with one tall wooden door ajar at the far end
Illustration. Not a photo of a real courthouse or of any hearing.Illustration: FinanceInTime

A New York judge is due to hear the state's request for a temporary restraining order against the prediction market Kalshi at 11:30 a.m. ET on Monday, November 23, after The Block reported that a federal judge refused the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) emergency bid to stop the case.

Two readings of the same order

New York's attorney general sued KalshiEX, LLC on July 31, saying it runs an unlicensed gambling operation, according to the attorney general's announcement. Letitia James said then that "prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple."

Kalshi moved that case to federal court. CoinDesk reported that a federal court sent it back to New York's Supreme Court on Thursday, and that an assistant attorney general filed a proposed motion for a restraining order on Friday.

The proposed order would bar Kalshi from running an unlicensed gambling business "within or from New York or to persons in New York," The Block reported. Kalshi's lawyer wrote that it "would shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere." The attorney general's office replied that it "does not seek to 'shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere,'" according to The Block.

The CFTC lost its Friday request

The CFTC, which regulates Kalshi as a federally registered exchange, asked a federal judge to stop New York from acting. Judge Lorna Schofield "denied the request from the bench after a telephone hearing," The Block reported. CoinDesk quoted the CFTC's filing as saying "New York wants to put Kalshi out of business altogether."

CoinDesk reported on Kalshi's exposure to a New York order and counted "the 1.2 million New Yorkers who use Kalshi." A Kalshi spokesperson, Elisabeth Diana, was quoted by CoinDesk as saying "We want to work with the governor and attorney general on a resolution."

What Monday's ruling would settle, and what it would not

The hearing before Justice Melissa Crane decides only whether a restraining order is issued while the case continues. It does not decide whether Kalshi's contracts are gambling or federally regulated swaps, a question the CFTC and the state dispute.

A court test for who regulates event contracts

We think the Monday hearing matters less for Kalshi's New York customers than for the question behind it. If the order reaches only trading by people in New York, an exchange can be asked to separate its customers by state. If it reaches trading "from New York," the same wording could apply to any exchange headquartered in a state that objects to its products.

The opportunity is a clearer ruling than the split among courts has produced so far. The threat is open positions closed at short notice if an order is read broadly, which Kalshi's lawyer says it would be. We do not forecast the outcome, and our view would change if the court limits the order to customers in New York.

The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.

Sources

  1. Governor Hochul and Attorney General James Announce New York Has Sued Kalshi for Running Illegal Gambling Operation — New York Attorney GeneralPrimary source
  2. Kalshi faces Monday hearing on New York order it says would shut down its exchange nationwide — The BlockSecondary source
  3. Kalshi races to get ahead of New York order that could shut down exchange — CoinDeskSecondary source
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google

More in Crypto

View All Crypto

Get Finance News in Your Inbox

Daily headlines, market insights and analysis from our editors.