Amazon warns New Yorkers of up to $5 per order, but the delivery bill sets no surcharge

The app message cites a cost the bill does not impose; Amazon has not explained the figure, and the bill's sponsor calls the claim dishonest while the bill sits in committee with 35 sponsors.

Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
Illustration of electric cargo bikes parked at the loading dock of a city delivery warehouse at golden hour
Illustration. Not a photo of a real delivery facility.Illustration: FinanceInTime

Amazon (Nasdaq: AMZN) is telling New York City shoppers in its app that a bill before the City Council "could add up to $5 per order," according to Fox Business, while the bill's sponsor says the text does not require any such charge. The legislation is Intro. 518, the Delivery Protection Act, and it is still in committee.

What the bill would require

The bill is sponsored by Council Member Tiffany Cabán. The mayor's office said the Delivery Protection Act "would create a licensing system for certain last-mile warehouses and distribution facilities while establishing new safety, training and labor standards." It would also "hold the company operating the facility, such as Amazon, responsible for employing the workers" who do the delivery work, per the mayor's announcement.

On cost, Cabán said the bill "would require companies like Amazon to pay a $500 licensing fee every other year," as amNewYork quoted her. Fox Business noted that the proposal "does not itself impose a $5 surcharge on customers."

What Amazon says it would cost

The app message reads "NYC Council could add up to $5 per order," followed by "Act now to protect low prices," Fox Business reported. Amazon did not say how it arrived at the figure. Fox Business said Amazon pointed to a study by the consulting firm AKRF estimating that the legislation "could increase annual costs for New York City households by $409 to $664," and that Amazon "did not explain how the annual estimates translate to an increase of up to $5 per order." Neither report says who commissioned the study.

An Amazon spokesperson told Fox Business: "As the City Council continues to review this bill, we want to be transparent with our customers about what it would cost them if it passes as written."

In its own testimony to the Council, Amazon said the bill "would prohibit our agreements with more than 40 local small businesses known as Delivery Service Partners (DSPs)" and would put at risk "the jobs of the more than 5,000 people they employ." The same testimony said the bill could "compel us to seriously examine how we could still meet our commitment to New Yorkers—which includes the potential for relocating operations and delivery facilities outside of New York City." Amazon's testimony states no cost to customers.

The city's side

Mayor Zohran Mamdani said in the announcement: "New Yorkers should not be forced to subsidize corporate profits with less safe streets and more precarious jobs." The announcement also said that "since 2017, at least 18 large last-mile facilities have opened across New York City, including 11 since 2020."

Cabán called Amazon's criticism a "spurious attack." She said: "It's simply dishonest to claim that this bill would require them to charge consumers $5 for every delivery." Council Speaker Julie Menin called the surcharge a "deceptive campaign" by Amazon and said: "It defies logic that Amazon, a $3 trillion corporation, would raise New Yorkers' cost of living if it's forced to adhere to basic regulations and worker protections." amNewYork reported that Intro. 518 "has 35 City Council sponsors and remains in the committee on consumer and worker protection."

We would test the $5 figure against the bill's own mechanics

We think the dispute is about who bears a change in labor structure, and that the $5 figure is a worst-case claim rather than a measured one: it comes from Amazon, its basis was not given, and the only fee in the bill that the sources describe is $500 every other year. Capital allocation is where strategy shows, and the real question for Amazon is whether employing delivery workers directly, or moving facilities, costs more than the subcontracting model it uses now.

The threat for the company is higher delivery costs or disrupted routes in its largest US city; the opportunity is that a licensed, directly employed workforce could raise service reliability. We expect little clarity on cost until the committee schedules a vote or Amazon publishes its method, and we would change our view if it shows a per-order figure close to $5. This is a view on corporate strategy, not a call on the shares.

The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.

Sources

  1. Mayor Mamdani Backs Delivery Protection Act — New York City Mayor's OfficePrimary source
  2. Amazon's testimony on Intro. 0518-2026 — AmazonPrimary source
  3. Amazon says NYC Council bill could add a delivery surcharge — amNewYorkSecondary source
  4. Amazon warns NYC shoppers of potential $5 per-order increase — Fox BusinessSecondary source
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google

More in Business

View All Business

Get Finance News in Your Inbox

Daily headlines, market insights and analysis from our editors.