EconomyAnalysis
Core inflation is 0.5 point lower by CPI than by PCE, and Fed minutes call it unusual
Total inflation was 3.7% by CPI and 3.6% by PCE in September, but core CPI was 2.6% and core PCE 3.1%. The Fed's October minutes call the gap unusual and do not explain it.
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
The two main US inflation gauges said much the same about total prices in September, 3.7% for consumer prices and 3.6% for the Fed's preferred measure, but they were half a percentage point apart on core prices, with core CPI the lower of the two.
Total inflation barely differs, core inflation does
The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) said the consumer price index (CPI) rose 3.7% in the 12 months to September, after 3.4% in the 12 months to August. The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) said the PCE price index, its measure of prices for personal consumption expenditures, rose 3.6% from a year earlier in September, after 3.4% in August.
Excluding food and energy, the picture splits. Core CPI rose 2.6% over the year to September, following 2.4% in August. Core PCE rose 3.1% in September, after 3.0% in August. Subtracting, the core CPI ran 0.5 percentage point below core PCE in September and 0.6 point below in August (computed from the four published rates). Total CPI was 0.1 point above total PCE in September and equal to it in August (computed).
The Fed sets its 2% goal in PCE terms: the Committee judges that inflation at 2% "as measured by the annual change in the price index for personal consumption expenditures" fits its mandate over the longer run. So the measure with the higher core reading is the one the Committee targets.
What the monthly figures show
The gap is not a story of one month. In September the CPI rose 0.6% on the month, seasonally adjusted, and the PCE price index rose 0.5%. Both core measures rose 0.3% in September. In August, core CPI rose 0.3% while core PCE rose 0.2%, the BEA said.
Energy was the main driver of the headline. The BLS said gasoline rose 9.1% in September and accounted for over half of the monthly increase in the all-items index, and the energy index rose 5.2% on the month and 20.4% over the 12 months to September. Energy carries a different weight in each index, and the releases do not state the weights, so the data here do not show how much of the headline similarity comes from energy.
October's CPI has no annual rate
The October CPI report shows the CPI rose 0.4% on the month after 0.6% in September, with core prices up 0.3% for a third month. The BLS said it did not collect survey data for October 2025 because of a lapse in appropriations, so it cannot publish 12-month changes for October 2026 for indexes where October 2025 data are unavailable. The annual CPI comparison with PCE therefore stops at September until November data arrive; the BEA's October PCE release is due on November 25, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. EST, according to its September release.
What Fed officials said about the discrepancy
The minutes of the Fed's October 27-28 meeting, released on November 18, show the staff estimated PCE inflation of 3.6% in September and core PCE of 3.1%, and attributed higher inflation largely to earlier tariff increases, higher energy prices and upward pressure on goods prices tied to the AI buildout.
Some participants raised the gap directly. A few cautioned that market-based inflation expectations, derived from the pricing of securities indexed to the CPI, "might be difficult to interpret" given "an unusual discrepancy between CPI and PCE inflation rates." The minutes do not say what causes the discrepancy.
Participants also pointed to elevated inflation in market-based core nonhousing services and to measures of underlying inflation that remained above 2%. Almost all judged that further action to raise the target range would likely be appropriate, and a couple said an increase of more than 25 basis points could warrant consideration at the next meeting if inflation data were unfavorable. That meeting is on December 8-9.
Households absorbed the price rises in real income
BEA data show consumers absorbing the price rises. Real disposable personal income, which is income after taxes and adjusted for inflation, fell 0.3% in September after no change in August. Real PCE was unchanged in September after rising 0.5% in August. The minutes record that a few participants noted higher prices of necessities were straining the budgets of lower- and middle-income households.
The staff's forecast, as recorded in the minutes, is that total inflation steps down sharply next year as energy prices decelerate and is about 2% in 2028, with risks to the inflation projection skewed to the upside.
Reading the gap as a warning about the target, not about CPI
We think the half-point core gap matters less as a puzzle than as a statement about which gauge the Fed answers to. A core CPI of 2.6% would look like a Committee close to its goal; a core PCE of 3.1% looks like one with work to do, and officials are reading the second. The minutes do not link the gap to the October decision, but they show officials weighing it when they read CPI-based market signals.
The threat is that households, who live in the CPI basket, see 2.6% core inflation and judge the Fed's further increases hard to square with their own experience, while the opportunity is that a lower CPI core leaves room for real income to recover if energy prices keep easing. We expect core PCE, not CPI, to decide the December 8-9 meeting, if the next readings stay near current rates. We would change that view if the BEA's October release showed core PCE closing the gap to core CPI from above, which would suggest the discrepancy was temporary.
The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.
Sources
- Consumer Price Index - September 2026 — U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsPrimary source
- Consumer Price Index - October 2026 — U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsPrimary source
- Personal Income and Outlays, September 2026 — U.S. Bureau of Economic AnalysisPrimary source
- Personal Income and Outlays, August 2026 — U.S. Bureau of Economic AnalysisPrimary source
- Minutes of the FOMC, October 27-28, 2026 — Federal Reserve BoardPrimary source
- Statement on Longer-Run Goals and Monetary Policy Strategy — Federal Reserve BoardPrimary source
- FOMC meeting calendars — Federal Reserve BoardPrimary source
More in Economy
View All Economy


