Family Dollar settles price-accuracy claims for $63 million as a Dollar General case continues

The FTC and 17 states alleged registers charged more than shelf prices; a $40 million redress fund and $20 million discount program are proposed.

Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
Illustration of a store shelf edge with blank price strips and plain boxes with an empty checkout counter blurred behind
Illustration. Not a photo of a real store.Illustration: FinanceInTime

Family Dollar agreed on November 12 to pay $63 million to settle allegations from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and 17 states that it routinely charged customers more at the register than the prices shown on shelves, price tags and advertisements, according to the FTC's announcement. The order still needs a federal judge's approval.

What the order would pay and require

The proposed order sets up a $40 million consumer redress fund for eligible shoppers and a $20 million discount program for Family Dollar customers, the FTC said. Payments of more than $3 million will also go to the states. Family Dollar must tell customers whether they are eligible for redress by posting notices in its stores and on its digital platforms.

The order also bars the retailer from misrepresenting the price of its goods and requires a pricing accuracy program: regular monitoring and verification of prices, employee training to spot discrepancies and prompt correction of errors. The program must be independently assessed and annually certified. The FTC filed the complaint and a stipulated final order in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, and the agency noted that such orders carry the force of law once the court approves and signs them.

What the complaint alleges about the register

According to the complaint, thousands of Family Dollar stores nationwide overcharged shoppers, including in low-income communities with limited access to full-service grocery stores. The FTC said state and local regulators had cited the company for thousands of pricing violations in the last five years, with fines above $3 million, and that in the last three years Family Dollar paid more than $800,000 in penalties to state attorneys general and consumer protection agencies under earlier settlements.

The complaint also alleges that Family Dollar charged more at the register than the prices on its website and mobile app, and that shoppers did not receive the discounts shown on its Smart Coupons because the app failed. The FTC said the company's internal records show six years of complaints about the same app problems. The Commission's vote to authorize the complaint and order was 2-0. A complaint is an allegation: the FTC notes that it files one when it has "reason to believe" a law is being violated.

A second case against a larger chain is still open

On October 26, the FTC and 20 states sued Dollar General Corporation over similar practices, the agency said. The complaint alleges Dollar General received tens of thousands of consumer complaints that it did not honor the advertised price. The company operates more than 21,000 stores. That case is in the US District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee and has not been decided; the FTC said the court will decide it. Dollar General's response is not in the FTC's release.

Where the pricing rules leave household budgets

Our view is that the settlement matters less for its size than for what it says about where small overcharges hide: in shelf-to-register gaps and coupon apps, in stores serving households that watch every dollar. The threat for those households is a loss that is hard to notice, a few dollars at a time. The opportunity is a pricing accuracy program with outside assessment, which makes errors visible and gives regulators something to check. We think the Dollar General case is the better test of whether this becomes industry practice, and we would watch whether the court approves the Family Dollar order unchanged and how redress claims are handled. A forecast is uncertain: we expect other retailers to review their price-checking practices if the Dollar General case proceeds, but no source in the release says they will. We would be wrong if the redress fund pays out little against the number of eligible shoppers.

The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.

Sources

  1. FTC, 17 States Secure $63 Million Settlement with Family Dollar Stores — Federal Trade CommissionPrimary source
  2. FTC and State Partners Sue Dollar General for Charging Consumers More than Advertised for Many Products — Federal Trade CommissionPrimary source
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google

More in Personal Finance

View All Personal Finance

Get Finance News in Your Inbox

Daily headlines, market insights and analysis from our editors.