Indiana fund that promised 6% a month was a $560 million Ponzi scheme, SEC and CFTC allege
The regulators say Backward Hat Capital took money from more than 2,000 investors, spent over $220 million on its founders, and kept raising funds into October 2026. A court has frozen assets and named a receiver.
Add FinanceInTime as a preferred source on Google
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) alleged on November 20 that an Indianapolis fund group, Backward Hat Capital, ran a Ponzi scheme that took about $560 million from more than 2,000 investors, according to the SEC's announcement. A federal court has frozen the defendants' assets.
A promise of 6% every month
The SEC's complaint says the co-founders, Phillip Williams and Devin Johnson, raised money from about July 2022 to the present for what they described as algorithmic foreign exchange trading. The SEC said they told investors the money would be converted to crypto assets and used in a proprietary, "AI-driven" algorithm that they claimed always returned at least 6% per month.
The CFTC's announcement puts the figures slightly differently: more than $550 million from at least 2,100 participants, and historical returns of more than 6% monthly "without a single losing month." The two agencies' counts come from separate complaints.
A return of 6% every month, compounded over 12 months, works out to a gain of 101.2% a year (computed). Both agencies describe that pace of return as the lure, not as something the funds achieved.
Where the agencies say the money went
According to the SEC, the defendants made more than $250 million in Ponzi-like payments to earlier investors and transferred more than $220 million to themselves, about 39.3% of the amount raised (computed). The SEC said the money paid for exotic cars and expensive homes, other businesses the founders owned and Johnson's gambling.
The CFTC said the defendants conducted little to no forex trading and instead misappropriated participant funds or used them to pay fake trading profits to other participants.
The SEC also charged Joseph Anderson, who allegedly created fake financial reports for investors, including at least two "audit reports" and a "quality of earnings" report from a so-called third-party independent audit firm. The SEC said the reports falsely stated that the returns had been verified against bank and brokerage records, and that they contradicted the bank records.
What a court has done so far
The CFTC said the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana entered a restraining order on Wednesday, November 18, freezing the assets of the defendants and the relief defendants, who are people and entities said to hold scheme money they have no claim to. On November 20 the court appointed Kevin B. Duff as temporary receiver to take control of the company defendants and certain assets. The FBI arrested Williams and Johnson on Wednesday, the CFTC said.
The CFTC said the alleged fraud was ongoing, with the defendants soliciting funds at least through October 2026. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York has filed criminal charges against Williams and Johnson, according to the SEC.
The agencies' filings are allegations. Neither announcement includes a response from the defendants, and the charges have not been decided in court.
Why a steady return should raise a question, not lower it
We think the useful lesson in this case is arithmetic rather than technology. The SEC's own warning, from Anne McKinley, Acting Associate Director of its Chicago Regional Office, is that "the promise of a low-risk, high rate of return on a purportedly complex investment should make all potential investors stop and think before investing their money." A return that never dips is the feature that the CFTC points to first.
The threat for households is that the pitch borrowed the vocabulary of crypto and artificial intelligence, which many savers cannot check, and that audit-style reports can themselves be forged, as the SEC alleges happened here. The opportunity is that the checks are free and public: registration lookups on the regulators' sites and the SEC's investor education pages exist for exactly this situation.
We would treat a promised return that never dips as a question to ask rather than a reassurance, and weigh it against the risk the fund says it takes. Our view would change if the courts find the funds did trade as described, which the agencies' filings say they did not.
The view in this final section is FinanceInTime's editorial opinion, for information only. It is not investment, tax, legal or other advice, and it does not take your circumstances into account. Forecasts are uncertain and past results do not guarantee future ones.
Sources
- SEC Charges Indianapolis-Based Backward Hat Capital and Its Co-Founders With $560 Million Dollar Offering Fraud and Obtains Emergency Relief — U.S. Securities and Exchange CommissionPrimary source
- CFTC Charges 11 Companies and Two Indiana Executives in $550 Million Fraud Scheme — U.S. Commodity Futures Trading CommissionPrimary source
More in Personal Finance
View All Personal Finance

Personal Finance · Analysis
September's Fed rise reached card rates in full and left savings rates where they were

Personal Finance · Analysis
One-year Treasury yields fell below inflation in April and May, then rose back above it

Personal Finance · Analysis